Toro 51585 vs 51617, Which is Better?

Toro 51585 vs 51617… which of these yard tools is for you? Is it the Power Sweep or the Rake and Vac? To help you with the answers, first, you’ll need to know their differences. For this, let this comparison report be of help.

Comparison Chart: Toro 51585 vs 51617

Let’s start with this side-by-side comparison chart. It should serve as an easy-to-use reference.

Toro Leaf Blower
Model Check Price » Toro 51585 Check Price » Toro 51617
Other Name Power Sweep Rake and Vac
Weight 4.7 lbs. (2.1 kg) 6.5 lbs. (2.9 kg)
Maximum Air Speed 160 mph 215 mph
Speed Control 2 Speeds 2 Speeds
Air Volume (Vac Mode) N/A 350 cfm
Motor 7.0 amps 10.5 amps
Impeller Plastic Plastic
Leaf Reduction (% of debris reduced to <1/2") N/A 76% (Debris reduction varies with material type and its condition)
Inclusions N/A Concentrator, bottom-zip bag

Key Differences

Based on the chart and the data presented above, it’s clear that these two yard tools are different from each other. Let’s discuss…

Functions

These Toro’s are also called by another name: Power Sweep for the 51585 and Rake and Vac for the 51617. The names give you an idea of what they can help you do, and they highlight an important difference.

The Toro 51585 is not a multi-functional tool. Meaning, it only acts as a leaf blower. It has enough air power to clean your driveway or rid your yard of leaves. But that’s its only function.

On the other hand, the Toro 51617 is a mult-functional gardent tool. As advertised, it’s a 3-in-1 appliance. When not used as a blower, it can be on Vacuum mode. Plus, it has the ability to turn leaves you collect into mulch (as a mulcher).

That said, expect that the Toro 51617 is more equipped with parts to ensure that you enjoy these other uses/functionalities. For instance, this leaf blower has a Quick-Release latch that allows you to transform it from a blower to a vacuum.

Also read: Toro 51619 vs 51618, Which is More Powerful?

Weight

There’s also a difference in weight. Which one’s lighter?

It’s the Toro 51585, which weighs only 4.7 lbs. (or 2.1 kg.). In comparison, the Toro 51617 weighs 6.5 lbs. (or 2.9 kg.).

Air Speed and Air Volume

With both leaf blowers, you’ll get to choose between two speed settings.

However, as expected, the Toro 51585 is not as powerful as the Toro 51617. When it comes to air speed, it has a maximum velocity of 160 mph, which is way lower than the 215 mph velocity of the Toro 51617.

And since the Toro 51585 doesn’t have a Vacuum mode, there is no data available for its air volume unlike with the Toro 51617, which has a rate of 350 CFM.

Motor

Both of these leaf blowers have a plastic impeller fan, but their motors have different amp values. The Toro 51585 runs on a 7-amp motor while the Toro 51617 runs on a 12-amp motor.

Debris Reduction

The Toro 51585 doesn’t have a mulching functionality, but the Toro 51617 has this feature. According to the data we collected, the leaf reduction rate of the 51617 is up to 76%, depending on the type of debris it manages to collect.

Also read: Toro 51618 vs 51617, Which Leaf Blower to Get

Our Final Word: Toro 51585 vs 51617

Which of these two Toro yard tools should you get? Here’s what we have to say.

The Toro 51585 is ideal for very light tasks related to sweeping off debris and other stuck-ons on patios, pathways, and garages. However, if you want a multi-functional yard tool that can handle different types of tasks related to vacuuming, mulching, and getting rid of leaves, then get the Toro 51617.

Alternatives to Toro Leaf Blowers

Unimpressed with these Toro leaf blowers? How about these three options?